Released on March 27, 2023, "Lost at sea" is Hayley's fifth studio album. The record is an alt-pop record with storytelling and folk influences. Rodrigo narrates the age-old story of a boy and girl romance, but she captures the essence of the subject and puts her passion into the songs, leaving listeners intrigued and eager for more. Her command of language keeps them on edge. The alt-pop record includes collaborations with Sweetener and multiple co-writing credits from Elle Serin. With her folk narrative and uplifting ballads, Hayley laid the groundwork for the alt genre.